SQE Contract Law: Exploring Landmark Cases That Shaped the Field

Welcome to our blog! Today, we will be diving into the world of contract law and exploring some of the landmark cases that have shaped the field. Contract law plays a crucial role in our legal system, governing agreements between individuals, businesses, and organizations. Understanding these landmark cases can provide valuable insight into the development and interpretation of contract law principles. So, let’s explore some of these influential cases that have shaped the field of contract law throughout history.

1. Carlill v. Carbolic Smoke Ball Company (1893)

In this famous case, the Carbolic Smoke Ball Company advertised a product that they claimed could prevent influenza. Mrs. Carlill, who purchased the product and used it according to the instructions, still contracted influenza. When the company refused to honor their promise to pay £100 to anyone who caught influenza after using their product, Mrs. Carlill sued.

This case established the principle of unilateral contracts, where a promise is made by one party to another without the need for a formal acceptance. The court held that the advertisement constituted an offer and Mrs. Carlill’s act of purchasing and using the smoke ball constituted acceptance of that offer. This case reinforced the fundamental elements of contract law, such as offer, acceptance, and consideration.

2. Hadley v. Baxendale (1854)

In this seminal case, Hadley, a mill owner, sued Baxendale, a carrier, for losses resulting from a broken crankshaft. The issue at hand was whether Baxendale should be held liable for damages that were not within the contemplation of the parties at the time of the contract.

The court held that damages can only be recovered if they arise naturally from the breach of contract, or if they can be reasonably supposed to have been in the contemplation of both parties at the time of the contract. This case established the rule known as the “Hadley rule,” which has been widely adopted in contract law jurisdictions to determine the extent of recoverable damages.

3. Donoghue v. Stevenson (1932)

Donoghue v. Stevenson is a famous case in the field of contract law that also had profound implications for product liability. In this case, Mrs. Donoghue consumed a bottle of ginger beer that contained the remains of a decomposed snail. As a result, she suffered from shock and gastroenteritis.

The court held that the manufacturer of a product owes a duty of care to the consumer, even in the absence of a contractual relationship. This case established the principle of “duty of care,” which forms the foundation of product liability law and has had a lasting impact on consumer protection.

4. Balfour v. Balfour (1919)

In Balfour v. Balfour, Mr. Balfour, a civil servant stationed in Ceylon (now Sri Lanka), made an arrangement with his wife to provide her with £30 per month while he was away. However, the couple later separated, and Mrs. Balfour sued for maintenance.

The court ruled that the agreement between Mr. Balfour and his wife was not legally binding because it lacked the intention to create legal relations. This case established the importance of the intention to create legal relations in determining whether an agreement is enforceable. It demonstrated that not all agreements between parties are intended to be legally binding, and some may be based on purely domestic arrangements.

5. Fisher v. Bell (1960)

Fisher v. Bell is an important case that deals with the concept of an invitation to treat versus an offer. In this case, a shopkeeper displayed a flick knife in his shop window. The relevant law at the time prohibited the “offer for sale” of flick knives. The police charged the shopkeeper with “offering” such knives for sale.

The court held that the display of an item in a shop window is merely an invitation to treat and not an offer. The customer, by taking up the item from the display, is making the offer. This case clarified the distinction between offer and invitation to treat, which is vital in understanding the formation of contracts.

These landmark cases have had a profound impact on the development of contract law, setting precedents and establishing legal principles that continue to shape the field today. Understanding the underlying reasoning and principles in these cases is essential for aspiring solicitors and law professionals.

If you found this article informative, you might also be interested in reading our related articles:

We hope you enjoyed this exploration of landmark contract law cases. Stay tuned for more informative articles!